Sentry New Mexico UM/UIM Settlement

Sentry and related insurers agreed to a $2.75 million settlement for certain New Mexico auto-policy customers. People whose underinsured-motorist claim was reduced by the at-fault driver’s payment may claim up to $25,000. Other eligible customers who paid for uninsured or underinsured motorist coverage during the class period are scheduled to receive a partial premium refund automatically.

Sentry New Mexico UM/UIM Settlement
New

Who is included in the settlement?

The class includes certain New Mexico Sentry auto-policy customers from October 1, 2010 through December 31, 2022. You may qualify because an underinsured-motorist claim was reduced by the at-fault driver’s payment, or because you bought or paid premiums for UM/UIM coverage under a qualifying policy effective before January 1, 2022.

How much can an Offset Subclass member receive?

A person with a qualifying underinsured-motorist offset claim may receive up to $25,000 after submitting a valid claim. If approved claims exceed the money allocated to this group, individual payments may be reduced proportionally.

Who receives an automatic premium refund?

A class member who does not submit a qualifying offset claim but bought UM/UIM coverage during the class period will automatically receive a check. The refund depends on premiums paid and the amount remaining after valid offset claims and approved settlement expenses.

How do I file an offset claim?

Sign and mail the claim form by January 8, 2027. People identified as potential Offset Subclass members may file online using the Unique ID and PIN from their mailed postcard. The administrator will verify the claim against Sentry’s business records.

Does an uninsured-motorist claim qualify for the up-to-$25,000 payment?

No. The special payment applies to underinsured-motorist claims reduced by what the at-fault driver’s insurer paid. If the at-fault driver had no liability insurance, the notice treats that as an uninsured-motorist claim and says it does not qualify for this option.

Do I need supporting documents?

The notice requires a signed claim form for an Offset Subclass payment and says Sentry’s records will verify the claim. It does not direct claimants to submit separate loss documents. The automatic premium refund requires no claim or supporting documents.

How do I opt out?

Mail an individual signed exclusion request postmarked by December 24, 2026. It must identify the case, give your full name and current address, and clearly say that you want to be excluded. Opting out means no settlement payment, but it preserves your ability to sue separately.

How do I object?

Mail a Notice of Intent to object postmarked by December 9, 2026. The notice lists detailed requirements, including your contact information, reasons and legal support, witnesses, lawyer information, and whether you plan to appear. You cannot both object and opt out.

Does the notice state the final hearing date?

No. The retained seven-page notice discusses a Final Fairness Hearing and objection procedures but does not give the hearing date, time, or location. Check the settlement website or contact the administrator for information rather than guessing.

Other Important Dates

  • Exclusion deadline: 2026-12-24
  • Objection deadline: 2026-12-09

Case Details

  • Total settlement fund: $2,750,000.00
  • Case name: Maria Coto v. Dairyland Insurance Company and Sentry Insurance Company
  • Case number: 25-cv-00160
  • Court: U.S. District Court for the District of New Mexico
  • Administrator: Coto v. Sentry Insurance Company Settlement Administrator
  • Official Settlement Website: https://www.NMUIMClassSettlement.com

Sources

Official Settlement Website
Claim form, FAQ, deadlines, administrator information
Visit Site →
Official Settlement Notice (PDF)
Court-approved notice describing eligibility and benefits
Open PDF →
Official NoticeRead the full notice

Official Notice

Read the notice PDF or the text version below.

Information last updated on 2026-11-20